Skip to main content

Which educational reforms make sense


We have two sets of primary and secondary schools in this country. One set of schools lies in wealthy areas in which student achievement is quite high. The other set of schools lies in poor urban areas or extreme isolated rural areas in which poverty is pervasive and student achievement is dismal. We know what to do to improve the quality of education in under performing schools. As a country, we do not have the will to do it. There are several reforms that will make education so much better for those in poverty.

Increase Early Childhood Education
The Chicago economist, James Heckman, Nobel prize economist, analyzed data from Michigan and North Carolina going back several decades and found that no other infusion of public dollars came close to matching the rate of return of high-quality early childhood education. Heckman's studies in both the Michigan (the Perry Preschool Study) and North Carolina (the Abecedarian preschool program) studies concluded that there were significant health benefits, increased employment and increased education among young children studied over their lifetime.

Develop the Whole Child
The current clamoring to focus on cognitive skills is absurd. There is ample evidence that a more holistic education approach pays big dividends. One study, a 2016 study at the University of Southern California’s Brain and Creativity Institute, found that musical experiences in childhood can actually accelerate brain development, particularly in the areas of language acquisition and reading skills.  "Music ignites all areas of child development and skills for school readiness: intellectual, social and emotional, motor, language, and overall literacy. It helps the body and the mind work together" (Bright Horizons). Yet what has happened to musical programs in schools since the adoption of No Child Left Behind and its successor programs? Schools focus only on cognitive skills and have eliminated music programs.

There are several studies that demonstrate a link between arts education and academic achievement. It is a story similar to the effect music education has on academic achievement. James Catterall among others has studied the link between arts education and academic achievement for low-income students. He found that low-income and ELL (English Language Learners) students do better in arts-rich rather than arts-poor schools. Ample evidence exists for a far more holistic approach that includes music an arts programs as a vital part of a young person's education.

Vocational Education & Links to Industry
There were many absurdities to the federal law, No Child Left Behind, and its successors but the worst was that all children needed to be college ready. Whatever happened with working with our hands? As a public servant working in city and state government and later as a university professor, I can attest that my electrician made more money than I did. No matter how technology changes, we will always need electricians, woodworkers, plumbers, etc. When our country started replacing shop classes with computer labs, we started down a very foolish road. This does not mean we should ignore the new technologies but we can incorporate new technologies into close ties with the vocational world and link our schools to industries that hire our graduates. This is one strategy that Mayor Bloomberg adoped. He greatly increased the number of technical high schools and linked these schools to industry.

Lessen Testing Requirements
There is ample evidence that emphasis on testing simply means that teachers and administrators focus on constant drilling and less teaching and learning. However, the evidence is ignored. I will leave you with just one website that explains testing. However, what the emphasis on testing in our schools does do is ignore all the other skills are students need - social and emotional, motor, language, and my favorite, music and art. More on testing in another blog.

Understand the Effects of Poverty on Children
I don't think Americans appreciate how poverty affects learning. Part of this ignorance is because those who now control educational policy reform in this country are not from the education world but rather from the private sector. These business leaders are ignorant of child development theories, do not travel in the educational world and are not exposed to educational theories about the basic concepts of child development, and they tend to hire whiz kids from the "best" colleges who have no understanding of how children learn, let alone children in poverty. I once talked to an educational policy analyst for the Bloomberg administration who would not dream of reading an education journal. She did, however, read the Harvard Business Review. If you wish to understand how poverty affects learning, read the article, "How Poverty Affects Classroom Engagement," in Educational Leadership or read the "Long Term Cognitive and Academic Effects of Early Childhood Education on Children in Poverty" in Preventive Medicine. Although I myself read the Harvard Business Review, I also read education journals that have the latest in child development theories. Also read Cantor on poverty and trauma. .

If we were simply to make these changes in our schools: increase preschool education, develop holistic education, lessen testing requirements, and expand vocational education and provide more links to industry, we would see improvements in under performing schools. If we were to reduce poverty, we would see massive positive changes in our schools.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Federal Abandonment of Public Housing

Public housing began during the Roosevelt years. In 1937 President Franklin Roosevelt signed the United States Housing Act, known as Wagner-Steagall, to support building low-rent public housing. In the wake of  President Truman‘s surprise reelection in 1948, Congress passed the bill now known as the Housing Act of 1949 and re-authorized the public housing program. The GI Bill after World War II supported veterans in securing low-interest loans to own their own homes. In the 1950s Congress passed a second Housing Act focused on conserving and rehabilitating low-income housing. All these laws favored white people.

The 1950s were famous for "urban renewal" which meant that the federal government provided grants for slum clearance that often meant cities would choose the poorest section of town to abolish residences and build new construction.

 In the 1960s, public housing became less discriminatory with Kennedy's Equal Opportunity in Housing Act. President Johnson elevated…

When the government doesn't open

Trump held 8 of the 12 federal appropriation bills hostaged. These eight were Homeland Security; Agriculture; Commerce, Justice and Science; Energy and Water Development; Financial Services and General Government; Interior and Environment; State and Foreign Operations; and Transportation and HUD.

For those who want a simple way of looking at it, here are the departments that were closed except that some federal employees were told to come to work even though they were not getting paid -

Department of the TreasuryDepartment of AgricultureHomeland Security DepartmentDepartment of the InteriorDepartment of StateDepartment of Housing and Urban DevelopmentDepartment of TransportationDepartment of CommerceDepartment of JusticeMore than 420,000 of the 800,000 furloughed had to come to work even though they were not getting paid. This included the air traffic controllers, coast guard, the FBI and border security. Even a few IRS agents were called back to work - no paycheck however. 
Democrats wi…

Recognizing the Power of Tribalism

I live in Charlottesville. Last year on a Friday night, I witnessed three hundred, young, white, angry men march with tiki torches through the grounds of the University of Virginia. Undeterred, these young men shouted Nazi slogans, surrounded the Jefferson statute, and proceeded to beat students and faculty who were brave enough to tell them to go home.

     The next day these hundreds of young men armed with sticks, shields, and masks descended onto a small park (Lee Park) near the Downtown Mall to protest the city's decision to move General Robert E. Lee's statute. Shouting the same Nazi slogans as the evening before (their favorite was "Jews will not replace us"), these angry young men were accompanied by armed militia who were older with serious armament. (In case you didn't know by now, Virginia is an "open-carry" state which means I can walk into Kroger's and see a shopper with a rifle.)

     That Saturday, as I watched the protest grow m…