Skip to main content

TANF's Long Reach



This is about one of the worst laws signed by President Clinton - the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), which dramatically cut cash benefits to the poor and limited cash benefits to five years. States could choose to adopt this portion of the law - to restrict poor families from receiving additional benefits when they have additional children. 14 states currently adopt this rule: Arizona, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Massachusetts, Mississippi, North Carolina, North Dakota, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia. How does it work? In Massachusetts, a single parent with two children receives $578 in TANF benefits each month. But if a second child is born while the family is already receiving TANF, that child is ineligible, and the family receives $100 less, for a grant of $478. 22 states originally adopted the cap and so far, 8 states repealed the cap, the most recent is New Jersey. 

You can imagine the comments from conservatives. "If they get more money for more babies, they will just keep having babies." That is the most common racist and sexist refrain. Never mind that no one would have an incentive to have another baby for $100 a month or that several studies demonstrate there is no incentive. Facts don't matter; just prejudices. If you find yourself agreeing with conservatives, follow the above link to the best study completed by the Center on Reproductive Rights and Justice at Berkeley Law (CCRJ). In an extremely well- documented study, the authors lay out the dubious assumptions underlying such prejudices. It is a good read.


The idea, that some people will have babies irresponsibly and therefore must have their reproduction controlled by authorities, can be traced back to the eugenics movement and the push to sterilize poor women at the beginning of the 20th century. Hitler was quoted as saying that Germans needed to study what America was doing in its sterilization program. Sterilization efforts continued way into the 1960s and 1970s. The Southern Poverty Law Center filed a lawsuit in 1974 demonstrating that between 100,000 to 150,000 sterilizations were occurring each year under federally funded programs. PBS' Independent Lens gave a poignant documentary about the impact of sterilizations on girls, some as young as nine. Yes, it is the case that capping the cash benefits when a recipient had another child is a far cry from sterilization. But it comes from the same thinking - that the state must control women's reproduction.


Meanwhile, slowly we are reversing the trend of punishing women for having children by reducing their cash benefits. Where there were 22 states capping cash benefits in the 90s, now there are only 14. We need to make it 0.











Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Federal Abandonment of Public Housing

Public housing began during the Roosevelt years. In 1937 President Franklin Roosevelt signed the United States Housing Act, known as Wagner-Steagall, to support building low-rent public housing. In the wake of  President Truman‘s surprise reelection in 1948, Congress passed the bill now known as the Housing Act of 1949 and re-authorized the public housing program. The GI Bill after World War II supported veterans in securing low-interest loans to own their own homes. In the 1950s Congress passed a second Housing Act focused on conserving and rehabilitating low-income housing. All these laws favored white people.

The 1950s were famous for "urban renewal" which meant that the federal government provided grants for slum clearance that often meant cities would choose the poorest section of town to abolish residences and build new construction.

 In the 1960s, public housing became less discriminatory with Kennedy's Equal Opportunity in Housing Act. President Johnson elevated…

When the government doesn't open

Trump held 8 of the 12 federal appropriation bills hostaged. These eight were Homeland Security; Agriculture; Commerce, Justice and Science; Energy and Water Development; Financial Services and General Government; Interior and Environment; State and Foreign Operations; and Transportation and HUD.

For those who want a simple way of looking at it, here are the departments that were closed except that some federal employees were told to come to work even though they were not getting paid -

Department of the TreasuryDepartment of AgricultureHomeland Security DepartmentDepartment of the InteriorDepartment of StateDepartment of Housing and Urban DevelopmentDepartment of TransportationDepartment of CommerceDepartment of JusticeMore than 420,000 of the 800,000 furloughed had to come to work even though they were not getting paid. This included the air traffic controllers, coast guard, the FBI and border security. Even a few IRS agents were called back to work - no paycheck however. 
Democrats wi…

Recognizing the Power of Tribalism

I live in Charlottesville. Last year on a Friday night, I witnessed three hundred, young, white, angry men march with tiki torches through the grounds of the University of Virginia. Undeterred, these young men shouted Nazi slogans, surrounded the Jefferson statute, and proceeded to beat students and faculty who were brave enough to tell them to go home.

     The next day these hundreds of young men armed with sticks, shields, and masks descended onto a small park (Lee Park) near the Downtown Mall to protest the city's decision to move General Robert E. Lee's statute. Shouting the same Nazi slogans as the evening before (their favorite was "Jews will not replace us"), these angry young men were accompanied by armed militia who were older with serious armament. (In case you didn't know by now, Virginia is an "open-carry" state which means I can walk into Kroger's and see a shopper with a rifle.)

     That Saturday, as I watched the protest grow m…